Skip to content
  • Free to use. No watermark. No sign-up.

American Birthday Traditions: Sweet Sixteen, Cake and the Song

Many American birthday traditions are younger than they look. The children's party with cake and candles came from Germany in the nineteenth century, the sweet sixteen grew out of the debutante ball in the 1920s, and the best-known birthday song was the subject of a copyright dispute that ended only in 2016.

The children's party: a German import

Historian Elizabeth Pleck, in her book Celebrating the Family (2000), traces the modern children's party to the German Kinderfeste of the early 1800s. According to the University of Minnesota's summary of her research, wealthy Protestant parents in the United States began holding children's parties in the 1830s, and the custom took about a century to reach the rest of the population.

The early parties were formal and run by parents, with as many as 40 children invited and an emphasis on teaching manners. In the 1920s parties became smaller and more centred on the child's friends. In the 1950s parties at places such as museums, pools and bowling alleys appeared, and from the 1980s parties increasingly moved out of the home and were run by a new party industry.

Cake, candles and the wish

The Encyclopedia of Recreation and Leisure in America says Americans took the idea of a birthday cake directly from the Kinderfeste. The birthday child makes a private wish and tries to blow out the candles; tradition holds that the wish comes true if every candle goes out with the first breath. Party-planning books of the 1920s suggested inviting one guest for each year of the child's age. The same encyclopedia describes the piñata, now a feature of many children's parties, as a tradition imported from Mexico.

The birthday song and its court case

The melody of "Happy Birthday to You" comes from "Good Morning to All", traditionally attributed to the sisters Mildred J. Hill and Patty S. Hill in 1893, although that attribution is disputed. According to Wikipedia, the tune and the birthday words first appeared together in print in 1912.

A copyright registered in 1935 was later acquired by the music publisher Warner/Chappell, which collected licence fees for the song. In 2013 a documentary filmmaker, Jennifer Nelson, brought a class action against the company. On 22 September 2015 a federal judge ruled that the copyright covered only a specific piano arrangement, not the melody and words. Warner/Chappell agreed in February 2016 to pay $14 million to people who had licensed the song, and when the settlement was approved on 30 June 2016 the court declared the song to be in the public domain in the United States.

Sweet sixteen

A sweet sixteen is a coming-of-age party for a 16th birthday, associated mainly with the United States and Canada. It is held for girls and boys but is more common for girls. Pleck dates it to the 1920s, when it emerged as a middle-class counterpart to the debutante ball.

Wikipedia's page, which relies mostly on popular sources, describes ceremonies that some families include:

  • Candle lighting: typically 16 candles, each given to a relative or friend with a few words about why that person matters.
  • Shoe ceremony: a father or another male relative helps the birthday girl change from flat shoes into high heels.
  • Tiara ceremony: her mother or another woman close to her places a tiara on her head.

The fifteenth birthday has its own celebration among many Latino families in the United States; see our quinceañera guide.

Milestone birthdays: why 21 matters

The 21st birthday is tied to alcohol law. The National Minimum Drinking Age Act, signed on 17 July 1984, cut federal highway funding for any state that allowed people under 21 to buy alcohol or possess it in public. By 1995 all 50 states were in compliance. The act did not itself outlaw drinking by people under 21, and Puerto Rico and the US Virgin Islands kept a minimum age of 18.

Birthday punches and a pinch

The Chambers Book of Facts, cited by Wikipedia, records "birthday punches" in the United States: one for each year of age. In some places the extra one for luck is replaced by a pinch "to grow an inch".

American birthday traditions at a glance

CustomWhat happensWhere it comes from
Children's partyFriends, games, cake and giftsGerman Kinderfeste; in the US from the 1830s
Candles and wishA silent wish, then all candles blown out in one breathCake custom taken from the Kinderfeste
PiñataThe child who breaks it open is said to have good luckImported from Mexico
Sweet sixteenComing-of-age party, sometimes with candle, shoe and tiara ceremonies1920s counterpart to the debutante ball
21st birthdayMarks the legal age to buy alcoholFederal act of 1984; all states by 1995
"Happy Birthday to You"The song whose copyright was fought over in court1893 melody; public domain in the US since 2016

What we left out

Two popular claims did not survive checking. The story that birthday candles began in ancient Greece is not established. And we found no reliable source for the history of "smash cakes" or goody bags, so they are not described here.

A card in the American spirit

For an American-style milestone, make a card for a sweet sixteen or a 21st birthday. More countries are on our birthday traditions page.

Sources

Related guides